Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Neural Foundry's avatar

That closng point about debates not validating positions hits hard. Just because shipping companies are discussingbattery-powered cargo ships doesnt mean the physics suddenly work better. I watched a boardroom once spend hours debating whether to implement a tech solution that literally violated thermodynamics, and the seriousness of the debate somehow made people forget basic constraints.

Tim Tuggle's avatar

I am going to do my best to ingrain this thinking into the minds of my six grandchildren: "...the fact of there being debate on a topic does not invariably mean that one — or more — of the positions expressed in the debate are anything other than a) wishful thinking, b) a demonstration of derangement, c) a revelation of ignorance on the topic, or d) all of the above."

Thank you.

29 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?